
I have been pondering this question as I work on my new photographic vision and business plan. I have become acutely aware that most editorial or stock photography could be produced by any competent photographer with a decent, but inexpensive, camera. Apart from variations in composition and lighting few if any such pictures exhibit any discernible personal style that could lead a viewer to attribute any given picture to a particular photographer.
Thinking more widely it would seem that a distinctive, genuinely personal, style is a rarity. As casual viewer of landscape photographs I do not think I could tell the difference between uncredited pictures by Joe Cornish, Charlie Waite, David Noton and others. Even where I am arguably more knowledgeable, say photojournalism, I would probably struggle to attribute less known works of Cartier-Bresson, McCullin, Burrows and others except perhaps by subject, location or period. I might be able to guess at a picture by Bill Brandt or Diane Arbus but I could easily be fooled by the work of those they influenced.
Outside the more editorial or general stock areas then personal style does start to come to the fore. Obviously in high-end fashion, food and similar photography style and originality has always been important; one can think of Beaton, Donovan, Bailey, Wedge, Moon, Newton, Carlos-Clarke, Rankin and many others. However there are many photographers producing very generic work in the middle lower reaches of even this field where the images produced are well-lit pictures of clothes on attractive models but without any real personal style. It may well be that is what is required by their clients, to show the clothes rather than to excite the viewer with the virtuosity of the big-name photographer.
For many years I could identify at a glance pictures from the Trevillion picture library. While they still have a modern look that is different from Alamy, Corbis, Getty and micro-stock libraries it is now not so different from other libraries that target the street-credible, modern, edgy, conceptual (insert adjective of your choice) buyer. Is there a general homogenisation of photography, will the currently trendy libraries see their time pass too, only to get sucked into the mainstream?
Frequently what passes as style is a gimmick, perhaps currently it is the over-the-top high dynamic range or over-sharpened (separately or in combination) image. They are devices that are quickly copied and become a tired concept, even the early adopters or original creators will not accrue much advantage from it. It has always been the case, a decade or two ago the toy camera look was trendy (see the header picture) but that was soon passé. A few people still use it but mainly for the art market rather than more general publication. Before that is was spot colour, bas-relief, litho-printing and many more.
So there are three questions I am struggling with. Is a distinctive personal style important to the editorial or stock photographer who wants to rise above the mundane, or is it just a requirement for the assignment photographer? Secondly, or is a distinctive personal style even acceptable to buyers of editorial and general stock, or except perhaps for commercial use? Finally, is it even possible in fields such as travel or landscape photography to have a recognisable style, to genuinely be different? I still do not have the answers but I am working on it; please feel free to add your two-pennorth!
Add new comment