The times they are a'changing. The dominant camera technology of the last fifty or more years is being challenged. Digital photography means the single lens reflex (SLR) camera is facing the prospect of being replaced by mirrorless system cameras or even, for many users, by the smartphone.
Such a change makes sense from a technical, ergonomic and financial point of view. But as the old technology is increasingly challenged we have seen a burst of innovation in the capabilities of digital single lens reflex (DSLR) cameras. This increasingly appears to be an example of the 'sailing ship effect'—where an incumbent, and arguably obsolescent, technology has a final burst of innovation and development as it faces replacement by a new technology. The argument is that sailing ships went through more innovation in the last fifty years of their commercial use, when faced with the challenge of the new steam ships, than in much of the previous three hundred.
The SLR was the solution to the problem of interchangeable lenses on viewfinder cameras (as opposed to traditional view cameras). Other interchangeable lens cameras such as rangefinder cameras have generally been limited to a narrow range of lens focal lengths. Even Leica, typically, has only natively used 28mm to 90mm lens, wider and longer needed other solutions. Either a separate viewfinder for wider lenses or Visoflex adapter which effectively turned it into an SLR for longer lenses. SLR technology imposes a very rigid layout, bulk and adds significant mechanical complexity to the camera design.
Are we seeing the 'sailing ship effect' in regard to the DSLR? The addition for instance of video is an add-on that does not naturally fit with the design of an SLR. It requires it to switch to an electronic viewfinder in the form of live view. Other developments are being applied such as ever faster continuous drive modes which are irrelevant for most photographic purposes. Image stabilisation, WiFi connectivity and GPS capability are being added or improved along with ever more sophisticated autofocus and metering. That said, it can be argued that these are a general development that are also being added to non-DSLR cameras.
The DSLR still has advantages in some areas. Most notable perhaps is the autofocus performance which is enabled by being able to have a separate, specialised sensor (light directed to it by a semi-transparent mirror or similar). The challenger technology, mirrorless, still lag most DSLRs with regard to autofocus performance but the gap is closing with each new generation. The new, younger, technologies still have opportunity for significant step changes in autofocus and other capability as opposed to more incremental gains of the mature DSLR approach. There are still major opportunities for the flexible, all electronic, cameras to adopt new designs, new layouts, that shake off the constraints of the old mechanical camera layouts.
There are already professional and enthusiast photographers who have switched to the new mirrorless camera systems, usually those that are not shooting wildlife or action. They like the reduction in weight and bulk of the new systems. I still use a DSLR system for action but for everything else I use one of the latest mirrorless systems (Fuji). I will switch completely when mirrorless AF performance catches up (more or less), especially as I am shooting much less sport than I used to, possibly with the next generation. It may be as soon as 2016.
These are exciting times; and not just in photography as we may be seeing the start of similar major change in car technology. Anyway, as photographers we will benefit from the competition between competing technologies. It may well be the DSLR is obsolescent and will be replaced by mirrorless cameras for most purposes. It may be that the DSLR will survive as the preferred tool in some niches (difficult to see which though) just as range finder and view cameras have their proponents and applications. One gets the impression that the consumer DSLR is following compact cameras into terminal decline as most casual users use smartphones for their snapshots.
Mirrorless cameras will be the system of choice for serious photographers by 2020, probably earlier. By then DSLRs will be a niche product, only used by die-hard fans and those who are still seeking a return on their investment in a DSLR system. I would not invest in a DSLR system now unless it was the only solution (action etc.) and even then only then if will profitably repay its cost in a couple of years.
Add new comment